Trace Label V.A. : Un Hommage a Moondog, a tribute by..(var,2006)**°°

Many tribute cd’s have in their compilation of artists some people who understand the spirit of the dedicator, and show something of this spirit, even when shown from a different world or perspective. Then there are others who only take minor elements like tunes or melodies, but forget the spirit, or only half understand it, and were not really that much affected by it. Then there might also be a few parasites who take a tribute as a personal occasion to promote their music, without showing much significance. The best tribute cd’s are compiled by those who only accept the first kind of results.
I have the impression that the label themselves took the opportunity to promote a few artists, with a hope they should take such an advantage of an occasion completely seriously, and also asked Moondogscorner which artist whould give the most successful results. This means most music is somewhat interesting, holds itself more or less together, but we still have all three mentioned categories, no matter if the music is good or not.

In between the tracks, a few fragments from an interview with Moondog are added, giving extra insight into the man, and also a few street poems, narrated rather quickly.

There is no doubt that the essence of Moondog is clearly adapted and mixed with their own personality, by Stefan Lakatos, who was not only a pupil of Moondog, but who also plays his original instruments, and Xenia Narrati, who also had a full tribute cd, and had some lifetime dedicated to Moondog, something which leaves of course its clear marks (In my radioshow I said : "Xenia Narrati’s music sound as if it is warmed up like some wind up mechanical music
instruments.") If you really listen carefully enough to Moondog it should change your perspectives on music. Also a nice tribute is Guillaume Loizillon’s “tribal tribute” (in my radioshow I said : "Guillaume captures well the spirit of some essential element in the rhythm, of Moondog, (with piano) and takes it back to a tribal association, while leaving it classically inspired"). David Fench, seemed to have been honestly haunted by the melody of  “all is loneliness”, and plays his own, modest version. Jean Jacque Birgé combines harp, flute, loop glockenspiel, tape recording, and takes something of Moondog into a new modern mixing world, and is a fine attempt to do so. Also Konki Duet’s vocal rondo sounds like an honest tribute to me. This is comparable to the result of the last track by Production de l’invisible who makes a convincing enough theatre poetry based vocal interpretation based upon Moondog’s music. Although a bit far away from Moondog, Joseph Racaille’s piece with a loose medieval feeling, and with references to a different local regional subject, played by flutes and percussion, still fits nicely. Then we also have a few attempts which take the modern music world vision as their fundament, to such a degree this area is already of a different character compared to Moondog, but this does not mean this approach cannot be tried. Dragibus’s kind of remix into alternative pop sounds ok to me. Less acceptible I think is the use of disturbing noise, electronic sounds, with sounds as if from stone and iron, with electro-acoustic foundations like by Group D'Essai 3, because this is more disturbing in the Moondog context, because Moondog who has his origins in 19th century music and with ethno flavoured melodic and rhythmic and also with an inspirational purity of sounds and compositions ; in that case any factor of leading chaos and noise cannot fit with it at all. Also Pusse's track seems to fail any essence of Moondog’s music. Also ruthless “stealing” of samples of recordings to do just a chaotic remix, like by Samon Takahashi I am sure would have offended the master when it would have been done when he was standing next to this. The  few pieces with references to the folktronica genre can still convince me because of the same amount of rhythm and balanced sound exploration, with Mami Chan as one of the better examples, in a more Japanese softpop style (-In my radioshow I said : "Mami Chan gives Moondog’s music a new meaning, and made this bedroom pop lullaby, a free musical box inspiration."- followed by Norman Bambi who with his own humour said he left out the “moon” aspect because he will never go to the moon, and left the “dog” over ; the way he arranges guitar and computer rhythmic remixes was able to capture something of Moondog’s spirit for this modern world, and lastly, Jean Jacques Birgé. A bit more simplistic in approach is the Ilitch track, and Laurent Saïet also did a mix in a modern style. Then we have a few recordings which hardly have any association with Moondog. Hervé Zénouda is post-minimalism could recall the fact that Moondog had just a few rather minimalist pieces, but with a title like “a man on the moon” it is clear how little this has any reference to the original spirit of Moondog. 

Even when the compilation is not a completely successful tribute to Moondog in all degrees, much of the music on its own, with varied interests, can be interesting to hear. Also for the real Moondog fan there will be some very nice surprises. A more consistent compilation into one style, like for instance folktronica, or classical could have been a little bit more satisfying to use for repeated listens.

Audio : Stefan Lakatos : "Snaketime Rattle"(or here), Les Productions de L'Invisible : "Ceux Qui Inventment", Moondog : "Interview: I Had A Dog", Guillaume Loizillon : "Tribal Tribute"
& http://www.tracelab.com/03page/artiste/perso_022/Moon.html
& Ilitch : "Dogmood" on http://www.ilitchmusic.com/01pages/music/disco.htm
Info : http://www.tracelab.com/03page/artiste/moondog.htm (from http://www.tracelab.com/)
& http://demosaurus.free.fr/fenech/disco/cd/moondog.htm

Some contributors :
* Markus Muench : http://www.markusmuench.com/
* Stefan Lakatos : http://stefanlakatos.de
* David Fenech : http://demosaurus.free.fr/
* The Konki Duet : http://www.thekonkiduet.com/
* Dragibus : http://www.dragibus.jp/
* Xenia Narati : http://www.xenia-narati.de/xenia-narati.html
* Ilitch : http://www.ilitchmusic.com/
* Mami Chan : http://perso.orange.fr/doowop/biomami.html
* Norman Bambi : http://www.myspace.com/normannorman
* Les Productions de L'Invisibles : http://www.lesinvisibles.com
Epic Moondog : Moondog And his Friends -LP- (US,1953)***°'

The original liner notes of the full LP :

The music in this collection constitutes a series of tonal pictures with new sound variations and new tempo variations. The composer, and primary performer, is the tall, bearded musician, familiar to Manhattanites, by the name of Moondog. Although some of the melodies, and some of the tempi, are immediately congenial, their full flavor comes out on repeated listenings. This is complex music, with a sophistication that belies its seeming simplicity. Repeated hearings bring out further interesting combinations of sound, other subtleties of rhythm. Moreover, for all its apparently experimental technique, it is solidly grounded in classical forms, the most common being the round.
Moondog was born Louis Hardin, in Marysville, Kansas, and grew up in the west, where the percussion instruments of Indian tribes fascinated the boy. A chief named Yellowcalf taught him much about the manipulation of the instruments. When he was sixteen Moondog lost his sight, but took up the study of music at a school for the blind, learning theory as well as such instruments as the violin and viola. In 1943 he moved to Manhattan and began developing his own theory of music - sometimes referred to as "snaketime," because of its undulating sound - but went west again in 1948, to Arizona, studying again with the Indians. A year later he returned to New York, and began playing his unique instruments - many of his own construction and arrangement - on street corners.
This may seem a difficult way to propound a musical theory, but before long his ideas were seized upon by ranking professional musicians, who were fascinated by both the music and the musician. Particularly in the environs of Carnegie Hall are his theories respected, and in this collection many of the stringed instruments, the violi and 'celli, are played by members of the Philharmonic-Symphony Orchestra of New York. Perhaps the surest way to get at the heart of the music is to listen to it. These recordings, featuring Moondog, represent some of his finest compositions, and some of his most ingratiting ideas.

Dragon's Teeth: This number serves to introduce the trimba, a series of ten drums, triangular in shape, used in graduated sizes. Here the various rhythms of snaketime are introduced, beginning with 1/8 and moving up to 9/8. In the background, the composer's wife may be heard on the oo, a triangular instrument that sounds somewhat like a harp.
Voices of Spring: This is a short rhapsody of sound, using a background of sparrow's voices. Moondog recites a brief quotation on nature, and then plays a freely organized theme on the recorder.
Oasis: The coloring of this selection is predominantly that of Asia Minor, with a fascinating rhythm background. The instrumentation consists of piano, violin, the dragon's teeth (or trimba), the maracas and the uni. The uni is a seven-stringed instrument that can be plucked like a harp, struck with a mallet, like a piano, or played with a bow. It is this instrument that provides the provocative twanging sound. The violin and piano parts, incidentally, are played by two of the country's best young concert artists.
Tree Frog: This is an attempt to recreate in music the song of tree frogs in spring. A descriptive piece, its unique sound is produced by tapping the fingers against the openings of a recorder, with the microphone close-up. No air passes through the recorder in this unusual instance of a wind instrument used percussively.
Be a Hobo: This short song is a vocal round, with the composer singing both vocal lines. Here, as in most of the other selections, the counterpoint is evident. The melody itself, like most of Moondog's materials, is unpretentious, serving as a springboard, so to speak, for his metric experimentation, but nevertheless has a charming, sweet line that carries the music forward.
Instrumental Round: This is an experiment in orchestration, using strings, brass, woodwinds and percussion. All instruments are played by the composer himself, using tape recording.
Double Bass Duo: The genesis of this composition reflects the free, eclectic spirit of much of the music in this collection: the composer, having just bought himself a double bass, found himself locked out of the studio, and to pass the time began experimenting with its sounds. The thematic material evolved, then presented itself as a duet, and he promptly recorded it. The drum and both basss parts are played by the composer.
Why Spend the Dark Night with You?: Another of Moondog's compositions in the form of a round. His intention is to leave the meaning of the lyrics to the listener; often, he finds, more is read into the words than he intended.
Theme and Variations: On a four-note theme Moondog here builds one of his most ambitious orchestrations, using more than twenty voices played by himself. An interesting note on the percussion techniques: while playing the drums, he wore gloves with the finger-tips pulled slightly out, giving the extra dimension to the tone.
Rim Shot: This is a study in 5/4 time, example of acceleration in music. The work is scored for percussion only.
Both Suite No. 1 and Suite No. 2 are written in the twelve-tone chromatic scale used by the Vienese masters, such as Beethoven and Brahms. The classic tonal structure is used to evolve a five part invertible counterpoint. The Suites are parallel compositions; No. 1 is written in a minor-major-minor sequence, and No. 2 in a major-minor-major sequence. Moreover, the times of the correspoding movements are the same in both suites. Each movement is in canon form, separate thematically from its companion movements.
Suite No. 1: The instrumentation here consists of dragon's teeth drums (with gloves), two violi three celli and a set of five temple blocks. Throughout the entrances of the strings is in this order: 'cello, viola', 'cello, viola' and finally 'cello'. The first movement is in 7/4 time, the second in 5/2 and the third, where the composer's wife may be heard on the Japanese drums, is in 7/8.
Suite No. 2: The first movement here reverts to the initial instrumentation of the first Suite, and to the 7/4 time. The second movement, adding the woodblocks, temple blocks and claves mounted on a frame, is in 5/2 time. The final movement, again in 7/8, presents another new and intriguing instrument, the tuji. This is a sort of board with dowels mounted in rows. The dowels are fingered swiftly by the player, producing an unusual percussive sound.


Honest Jon's Rec.    Moondog : Moondog And his Friends 10" (US,1953)****°
Moondogs CornerMoondog : Moondog And his Friends 2006 (US,1953/1987/2005)****°

The original LP on Epic (EPIC LG 1002) has been carefully restored and remastered for this CD reissue, and the sound of the reissue is remarkably good. The album had found already a 10" reissue before. Also added on the CD were three bonus tracks of three dedicated people who recorded some Moondog's music between 1987 and 2005.

One must realize how Moondog must have learned music from native Indians, that his wife was Japanese (which might have had some influence too), and that he studied classical music. His ideas compiling the basics of different origins resulted in a series of self built instruments with a specific personal sound. Rhythm and sound seems to be more important foundations than the melody which caries. Some ideas are repeated from a core centre of sound and rhythm, but still reveal an open form, which makes the used rondo forms, like timeless areas, in which the circular forms also contains some spiral evolution pattern (just listen to “Dragon’s Teath”). On “Oasis” we hear how rhythmic layers are brilliantly and freshly combined with classical chamber variations (piano, strings). “Tree Frog” sounds like an improvisation on someone’s teeth in combination with wood or attached raw string, but actually, more remarkable, this is a percussive track on a recorder while playing it!! The short “double bass duo” theme gives a new droning perspective of a bass overload sound. These kind of short ideas come and go very quickly. There’s even so much new happening in a short time that the album and even each track just demands a repeated listen, something which is much more easy with a cd. Short themes with lyrics, rhythmical excursions, classical exploitations follow each other quickly. The main piece is a classical music suite in 2 parts, with the right intervals of complex rhythmic structures and percussion (written in 7/4, 5/2 and 7/8), with some variations of mood, of which Bach might have been an influence here and there. I am sure a few more listens will reveal much more to me.

The three additional tracks are by people who learned to play Moondog’s music and gave it some time to give it some special meaning to their lives. Stefan Lakatos was a pupil of Moondog. He plays a 7/8 rhythmical track, but strangely enough plays 4/4 on handshakers, so don’t use here the full meaning of complex interwoven vividness of what happens in Moondog’s compositions, is a much lighter version. It is played on the original trimba, one of Moondog’s instruments. Second track is a Moondog organ piece played by Paul Jordan, an organist who had played organ pieces with Moondog before. Last track is by Xenia Narati on harp, who, since 2003, plays Moondog’s music with her ensemble. This also shows a different, more modern times spirit making a good closer for the album.

Audio :  "Oasis", (or here), "Themes And Variations-Rim Shot", "Suite No. 1 (1st, 2nd & 3rd Movement)","Suite No. 2 (1st, 2nd & 3rd Movement)", "Tree Frog - Be A Hobo", "Suite No. One Third Movement"  
Info : http://www.moondogscorner.de/shop/
or for LP : http://moondogscorner.de/disco/rec3.htm
http://www.honestjons.com/shop.php?pid=28333
& http://www.geocities.com/moondogmadness/moondog_and_his_friends.html
Descriptions : http://www.forcedexposure.com/labels/moondogs.corner.germany.html
& http://www.squidco.com/...

Additional musicians from the bonus tracks :
Stefan Lakatos : http://www.stefanlakatos.de
Paul Jordan : http://moondogscorner.de/disco/rec25.htm
Xenia Narati : http://www.xenia-narati.de/tribute CD->
    LOUIS HARDIN
"MOONDOG"        
                          1916- 1999
Prog Folk-Folkrock-Acid Folk
Prog Folk-Folkrock-Acid Folk
CMoondog walked like this,
  in New York in 1956
  with his self-made clothes.



WHO WAS MOONDOG ?

A few sources will answer this question for me (under this I will add my meaning to these plane facts) :

I say one thing already. Moondog was a very in balance unique (real) 'fusion' artist with self-made instruments, classical compositions, and a great feeling for complex rhythms. He created music without being limited by any time's perspective.

A very specialised site I know is the following :  http://www.geocities.com/moondogmadness/. The only information about his father I would like to add : His father was a protestant missionary who visited more often clans from Indians and that's how Louis came into contact at an early stage with their rhythms.
In 1974 he was invited by the Hessischen Rundfunks (local television from Hessen, part of Germany) for two concerts. He will find a stay in Germany after that, and it seemed Amerika had forgotten him, untill the New Music America Festival in 1989. The magazine People said then : "New York has something to howl again- legendary Moondog is back".
If you want to add anything there, please contact him : moondogmail@yahoo.com

Another very specialised one with lots of pictures is (I used 3 of them here) : http://www.moondogscorner.de/
(with pages about anything interesting you can imagine concerning the man).

A list of still more or less available albums you can find at : http://oldies.about.com/entertainment/oldies/li...moondogdisc.htm
(more detailed list at first address)
Here you can also find a resume of his life :

Read about Moondog in the Early Years
Read about Moondog in the '50s and '60s
Read about Moondog in the '70s

A general  portrait you can find at : http://www.l-m-c.org.uk/texts/moondog.html      & http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moondog 

A another page with small reviews at http://www.kneeling.co.uk/pages/moondog/default.asp

An extra rare picture from the fifties of his and the cover of  "Moondog and his friends" you can find at : http://www.therefrigerator.net/music/music5.html 
An article with weird picture from 1970 by Steve Knowlton from Upstate
Magazine, February 22 : http://www.therefrigerator.net/music/music6.html
A recent Moondog interview from 1998 with recent picture, and Moondog's favourite music you can read at  : www.furious.com/perfect/moondog.html

Less important sources are :

A short review from his life and a picture from the second album (1956) you can see at : www.elvispelvis.com/louishardin.htm                   
You can listen to some samples at: www.3w-musik.de/Moondog.htm and at www.jpc-music.com/6995153.htm    and at : http://www.jazz-neuheiten.de/5746921.htm       

Music annotations from "The Common Calender" you can see at : http://furious.com/perfect/moondog2.html         
About Moondog's method of drumming there's an interesting page at : http://hem.spray.se/stefanlakatos/           

BUT WHAT DO I THINK OF MOONDOG'S IMPORTANCE ?

People will not have doubt now Moondog was an enigma. His first album has very serious music (piano, chamber orchestra) combined with animal noises, almost Japanese singing, a dance rehearsal, complex rhythms on strange self-made instruments , ending with a real NY street scene with his usual playing but also performing a wisdom inspired theatre play. His second album from 1956 is completely out of every time and space limitation. He uses self-made instruments in very complicated rythms, combines this with street noises, animal noises, wisdom words thrown in the streets of New York, combines sounds from a boat with a bamboo whistle and so on, but also classical inspired and very Japanese like melodies are being recorded there. A not to miss artifact.

His second but even more the third album delves more into complicated rhythms  on his self made instruments like the oo (triangular stringed instrument)  trimbas (triangular-shaped drum) and tuji (mounted sticks). These albums are still highly recommended.

His comeback in the seventies with Moondog and Moondog II are strange and seriously meant albums. The first one is orchestral work with added percussion. I once found this album in the waste sold out records from a collector shop ! How could they ! Moondog 2 are small rondo's and I like the mood in it very much which is pretty and gay. A very underestimated album from his.

Later Moondog recorded some albums for the German label Kopf Records. Like most of his albums every one of them has a different atmosphere. A New Sound for an old instrument is most unique a combination of rhythms with organ, and even organ is being seen as an instrument there that can produce some magical rhythms. In Europe is his most dark and not so accessible album.  H'art songs are songs at his old and sage age, speaking of a separated but very reflective world. Some of the songs possess humour :

"Enough about human rights. What about Wale rights ? What about snail rights ? What about seal rights ? What about eel rights ?"

His most sage words came most spontaneously on the albums before that.

Last years he was also busy with big bands. I heared some of it which reminded me somewhat at each other.

On Sax Pax for Sax he played this time a much more simple rhythm, almost like a heartbeat, a bit in the way the old Yahowha 13 played in rhythm control with his musicians. And only from thereon I could notice he became older.

I hope some more people will get access to hear Moondog at least once in his life.

A last anecdote :
The third album cover "The story of.."was designed by Andy Warholl's mother !

I will end with a grading of the earier reissued albums I have ( -purely graded as if it were just records of anybody unknown-)  :

Prestige      Moondog (1956)                                             *****
Prestige      More Moondog (1956)                                     *****
Prestige      The story of Moondog (1957)                           ****°
CBS           Moondog (1969)                                              ***°°
CBS           Moondog 2 (1971)                                           ****°
Knopf Rec.  Moondog in Europe (1978)                                ***°'
Knopf Rec.  Moondog : H'art Songs (1979)                           **°°'
Knopf Rec.  Moondog : A new sound for an old instrument (1991)  ****°
Knopf Rec.  Moondog : Elpmass (1991)                                       ****'
Knopf Rec.  Moondog & The London Saxophonic :
  Sax Pax for a sax (1994)          ****'
BMG           Moondog : Big Band (199?)                                      **°?

a bit more about "Sax Pax.." you can find at : http://music9.hypermart.net/...
a review from this album you can find at : http://www.ink19.com...

The newer reissues I reviewed on this page. review 1, review 2, LP, review 3 ->

An E-magazine with reviews from Moondog's albums you can find at : http://www.leisuresuit.net/Webzine/articles/moondog_obit.shtml        
a choreography-piece based upon music from Moondog 1 was once published at  http://abt.org/no_javascript/archives/ballets/moondance.html  

If you're curious to what some other old wise men made, see at the pages from Wulf Zendik, and from Ya Ho Wha 13.

reviews 1, reviews 2, review3, review 4, review 5, review 6, review 7


all links updated 2002, June 24th

go back to index

Moondog 1, 1969
Moondog 2, 1970
Moondog A new Sound of an old instrument LP-version
Moondog's A new Sound of an old instrument CD-version
Moondog's H'art Songs LP-version
Moondog's H'art Songs CD-version
Moondog in New York : "I don't dress to track attention, I track attention because I'm dressed as I do."
Moondogs CornerMoondog : Pastoral Suite / Surf Session EP (US,1953)****°

This is a limited ed. 500 mini-LP cover reissue CD of Moondog’s earliest release from 1953, originally a 7’ EP. It was originally recorded at the Spanish Music Center in New York City. No need to tell you this very individual musician was way ahead his time perspective and must have looked pretty weird with his self-designed clothes, playing his self-designed instruments on the streets of New York. This recording predates all earlier releases. The CD from the Prestige LP Moondog from 1956 showed a varied composer, with piano and orchestrated pieces, background noises and sounds (which was unusual to use as part of the composition), rhythmic skills etc. This mini-LP/CD wasn’t too different. These are 6 somewhat minimal-to-the essence pieces of around 1’40. “Pastoral Suite” with "Before The Storm", "The Storm", and "After the Storm", show a little bit more than the 1956 release where Moondog had his inspiration from. His child experience to play the powwow with the native Indians you can “feel” throughout the pieces. His Japanese wife must have given him some other ideas in use of dulcimer-like instrument playing. The use of environmental sounds, of complex rhythms might have been just an example of his own creative exploration genius. On the “Surf Session” side, “Snaketime Rhythms” with the sea in the background, and a sea boat whistle, mixed with complex rhythms and harp-like strings is meditative and fresh at the same time. Where Alice Coltrane, in a follow up of her husband, tried somewhat intuitively, new roads with her harp strings, Moondog, compared to Alice Coltrane sounds already in a different state of consciousness when making this track. “Duet” with his wife (with the same sea shore background) sounds like a mixture of Japanese and native Indian celebrative music. Last track, "Recorded Soliloquy", is a flute improvisation, for me a kind of duet with the sea shore atmosphere. Highly recommend !

Other audio : "Before the storm","Duet"
Info with audio : http://www.moondogscorner.de/shop/
Moondogs Corner   Moondog The Viking of Sixth Avenue (US,compilation 1949-1995)****°

A very good starter and well compiled tasty overview of Moondog's work, with first more focus on his early, short, rhythmically driven arranged ideas. Also shown in various tracks is his jazz corner influence. His classical influence gets less attention, but still is present, especially with "Chaconne in G major", a classical piece with powow rhythm, and with "Oasis" (second version) as the only included organ piece example, mixed with his typical rhythms.

Moondog had created many instruments to express himself, like the trimba (a triangular drum), the oo (triangular stringed instrument), yukh (a log suspended from a tripod, hit with two rubber mallets), tuji (mounted sticks of graduated lengths). Some influences include besides classical music and jazz, native Indian drumming, and Japanese music. Since the late 1940's, he also used environmental sounds in his recordings.

Audio : "Lament 1 'Birds Lament' ", "Oasis", "Enough About Human Rights", "Invocation", "Theme and Variations", "Down is Up", "Bumbo"
& http://www.juno.co.uk/products/193872-01.htm
Info : http://www.spincds.com/old/moondog2005.html
3 audiotracks with review : http://www.boomkat.com/item.cfm?id=19343
Reviews : http://www.allaboutjazz.com/php/article.php?id=19337
& http://www.phonicarecords.co.uk/detail.aspx?ID=8926
Article : http://www.metroactive.com/papers/sonoma/03.22.06/moondog-0612.html

New Moondog label :
http://www.managarm.com:80/

Moondog's music on myspace :
http://www.myspace.com/tugboattoccata
http://www.myspace.com/louismoondoghardin.

Process BookRobert Scotto : Moondog -book + cd- (US,2008) ???




review will be added soon








links will be added soon
Honest Jons Rec. Moondog : The Viking of Sixth Avenue (US,compilation 1949-1995)****°

review on
http://psychevanhetfolk.homestead.com/expmu2.html#anchor_78